A useful provenance record lets another curator follow what the collection knows about a digital collectible and where each statement came from. Start with a stable item identifier, a description, and the evidence available at the time of review. Keep the history of the item separate from the history of files used to display it. A replacement thumbnail, for example, deserves its own asset entry even when the underlying catalogue record stays the same.

Identify supported details, contributor reports, and open questions so the next curator can check a claim or correct the public description.

Give the item and its evidence distinct identifiers

Assign an item ID that remains attached to the catalogue entry when its title changes. Record the current title and any earlier title that appears in the evidence. Add a description that distinguishes this item from similar entries, such as the visible design, edition label, or format stated in the available material.

Give each supporting document or capture its own reference. A reference might point to an archived message, a dated catalogue export, or a file in the collection’s controlled storage. Include the date the curator examined it and a short description of what it contains. Another reviewer should be able to find the relevant material without relying on the person who first entered it.

Use a separate asset ID for each file used to represent the item. Record its filename, format, source, and relationship to the entry. A cropped preview and an original file can then be identified separately. If the preview is replaced, update the asset relationship and keep the previous file reference where it helps explain an earlier display.

Describe claims at the level the evidence supports

Use separate fields for the source’s statement and the curator’s assessment. If a contributor supplies a creator’s name, record that the contributor supplied it and link the relevant evidence. If a curator later checks a separate source, add the result and its reference. Do not turn a reported label into a verified attribution simply by copying it into a public field.

A practical working record can contain these fields.

  • Item identity. Stable item ID, current title, useful description, and known alternative titles.
  • Source statement. What the contributor or document says, with a reference and the date it was received or examined.
  • Review status. Supported, reported but unconfirmed, disputed, or awaiting review under the collection’s own definitions.
  • Representation. Asset ID, file source, and whether the file is the item being documented or an illustration of it.
  • Follow-up. The unresolved question, the person responsible, and the next review date when one has been agreed.

Use supported descriptions in the public summary. Preserve uncertain claims and their sources for review, and explain material uncertainties to readers.

Work through a fictional correction

Imagine that a community catalogue receives an entry called Blue Arcade Badge. Its contributor provides a small image and says that an artist named Mira Vale created the badge. The curator assigns item ID DC-042 and asset ID IMG-118 to the submitted image. The curator records the contributor’s statement and the date it was received, but leaves the creator field marked as unconfirmed because no separate supporting material has yet been reviewed.

The public card initially describes the badge’s blue arcade design. It does not present the suggested creator as established. The working record points to the contributor’s message and asks for evidence of the attribution.

Later, the contributor supplies an older catalogue entry with a different creator name, Lena Moss. A second curator examines the entry and stores a reference to it as E-024. The two sources now conflict. The curators retain both statements, record who supplied each one, and mark the attribution as disputed while they seek clarification. They do not delete the first message or silently replace one name with the other.

A subsequent message from the original contributor explains that Mira Vale photographed the badge rather than creating it. The curator records that clarification and its source, then assigns the image credit to Mira in the image record. The public item description can now distinguish the creator stated in the older catalogue from the photographer named by the contributor, with wording reflecting the collection’s review. DC-042 remains the item ID throughout.

When a clearer display image arrives, it receives a new asset ID. The curator links it to DC-042 and records the source and approval for that display. The earlier image reference remains in the history, so an editor can explain which file appeared on the first public card.

Review the record before and after a change

Before publishing a correction, ask a colleague to reconstruct the sequence from the record. They should be able to identify the item, find each source, and explain why the current public wording was chosen. Revise unclear fields before releasing the change.

After publication, compare the public card with the accepted record. Confirm the title, description, credit, and representation refer to the intended item and file. Add the public revision date to the history and leave open questions assigned for later review. When new evidence arrives, add a dated entry rather than overwriting the earlier account.

Frequently asked questions

What if the only evidence is a contributor’s statement? Record the statement and its source, and mark its review status clearly. Choose public wording that reflects what the collection can support.

Should a new image create a new item record? First decide whether the file represents the existing item or documents a distinct item. For a replacement representation of the same item, keep the item ID and give the file its own asset ID.

How much of the evidence should be public? Publish the details needed to understand the entry and its attribution. Keep private correspondence in the collection’s controlled records and provide an appropriate reference for authorized reviewers.

What happens when two sources disagree? Preserve both references and the precise points of disagreement. Record the review decision and the next question, and avoid presenting either claim more confidently than the evidence allows.

Categories: Collecting Records